HomeMy WebLinkAbout220412_Item 4.3_CorrespondenceFrom: David Eichar
To: City Council FORWARD
Cc: Whitehill. Brittany; . City Attorney; . City Manager
Subject: City council meeting of April 12th, item 4.3, SB 9 response
Date: Sunday, April 10, 2022 2:01:55 PM
CAUTION: EXTERNAL EMAIL - Ensure you trust this email before clicking on any links or
attachments.
Mayor, Council Members;
I believe the city attorney and staff may have misinterpreted SB9. You may also be interested
in what I found other cities are doing with SB9 and objective standards.
Instead of a objective standard being waived, it leaves modification of the standard up to
the director, sometimes with some guidance.
Normal setbacks are still required, except they can be modified/loosened to the down to
a 4 foot setback. For example, a 10 foot rear yard setback would still be required if an
800 square foot 2nd unit can be built on the property with a 10 foot setback. It is only
when the 10 foot setback would prevent an 800 square foot unit from being built, would
a lesser setback (down to 4 feet) would be allowed.
You do NOT have to set the side and rear setbacks at 4 ft. You can keep the existing setbacks
and only need to waive them if they preclude building an 800 square foot unit. For example,
"20% of the lot depth or 15 ft., whichever is greater, but not more than 40 ft.
maximum" for rear setback in R1 zone development standards.
Regards,
Dave
Setbacks
The state law is worded as such (bolding mine):
(2) (A) The local agency shall not impose objective zoning standards, objective subdivision
standards, and objective design standards that would have the effect ofphysically precluding
the construction of up to two units or that would physically preclude either of the two units
from being at least 800 square feet in floor area.
(B) (i) Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), no setback shall be required for an existing
structure or a structure constructed in the same location and to the same dimensions as an
existing structure.
(ii) Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), in all other circumstances not described in clause (i),
a local agency may require a setback of up to four feet from the side and rear lot lines.
https://Ieginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/biIlCompareClient.xhtmI?
bill id=202120220SB9&showamends=false
So, sub -paragraph (2)(A) is subordinated to sub -paragraph (2)(13)(ii). In other words,
the four foot setback requirement is only required if a greater setback would not allow
at least an 800 square feet unit.
Belvedere (bolding is mine)
hnpS7//WWW.cilyofbelvedere.org/DocumentCenter/View/778 I /Item -9
G. The proposed Two -Unit Development complies with all objective zoning standards,
objective subdivision standards, and objective design review standards applicable to the
parcel as provided in the zoning district in which the parcel is located; provided,
however, that:
1. The application of such standards shall be modified by the Director of
Planning and Building if the standards would have the effect ofphysically
precluding the construction of two units on a parcel subject to this chapter
or would result in a unit size of less than 800 square feet. Any
modifications of development standards shall be the minimum
modification necessary to avoid physically precluding two units of 800
square feet each on a parcel.
2. Notwithstanding subsection (F)(1) above, required rear and side yard
setbacks shall equal four feet, except that no setback shall be required for
an existing legally created structure, or a structure constructed in the same
location and to the same dimensions as an existing legally created
structure.
Note: "modified", not "waived".
Note: "all objective zoning standards", which includes side and rear setbacks of more than 4
feet.
Woodland
his://civicclerk.blob.core.windows.net/stream/WOODLANDCA/5af97f71-2096-4e63-b45e-
20d9c86faefl.PdLsv=2015-12-
11&sr=b&sig=Ga3sBoFB7dPjx%2B8TgkBpba7bOGJVKDPbVi5jE8ZCTV4%3D&st=2022-
03-05T02%3A34%3AOOZ&se=2023-03-05T02%3A39%3AOOZ&sn=r&rscc=no-
he&rsct=anPlication%2Fpdf
17.34.050 Requirements
F. Unit Standards.
e. Lot Coverage. Structures shall not cover more than 50% of the total lot area. This lot
coverage standard is only
enforced to the extent that it does not prevent two primary dwelling units on the lot at 800
square
feet each.
f. Open Space.
A minimum of 30% of the required rear yard shall be open space. This open space standard is
only enforced to the extent that it does not prevent two primary dwelling units on the lot at
800
square feet each.
Note, "only enforced to the extent", not "waived."
Garden Grove
https7//ggcity.org/sites/default/files/sb9ord2929.pd
CHAPTER 9.56 SB 9 TWO -UNIT RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTS AND
URBAN LOT SPLITS
9.56. 100 Development Standards and Design Criteria
D. Setbacks.
1. New Primary Dwelling Units. The following minimum setbacks from
the property lines shall be observed for each new primary dwelling unit
and any garages and accessory structures that are attached to a new
primary dwelling unit. Detached garages and accessory structures
shall comply with the setbacks contained in subsection 2. The
required setbacks shall be maintained open and unobstructed from the
ground to the sky, except for the permitted intrusions.
a. Front Setback: 20 feet
b. Interior Side Setback: 5 feet
c. Street Side Setback: 10 feet
d. Rear Setback: 15 feet.
4. Exceptions. The above minimum setback requirements do not apply
or shall be modified in the following circumstances
a. No increased setback is required for an existing legally
established structure or for a new primary dwelling unit that is
constructed in the same dimensions as an existing legally
established structure, provided that the new primary dwelling
unit shall not be greater than 800 square feet.
b. A required minimum setback may be reduced pursuant to
subsection W of this section to the degree it would (i) physically
preclude the development or maintenance of two dwelling units
on a lot or (ii) physically preclude any new primary dwelling unit
from being 800 square feet in floor area; but in no event may
any structure be less than four feet from a side or rear property
line.
Note, setbacks are greater than 4 feet can can be "reduced" to 4 feet, not "waived".
Saratoga
httVS7//www.saratoga.ca.us/DocumentCenter/View/2800/Ordinance-385-Urgency-Ordinance--
-Interim-SB-9-Ordinance
Lot Coverage. If application of development standards pursuant to this ordinance would
preclude construction ofdwellings with a combined floor area equal to the floor area allowed
for a dwelling by the underlying zoning district by City Code section 15-12.85, then the Two -
Unit Residential Development may exceed the maximum site coverage allowed for the
underling zoning distict in City Code section 15-12.080. Such exceedance shall be limited to
the minimum site coverage required to construct dwellings with the allowed floor area.
Note, the floor area is "limited to the minimum" required to construct the dwelling, not
"waived".